The Collingswood Story (2002) Movie Review - Pioneering Early 2000's DIY Horror Gem

Welcome to Knockout Horror and to another entry into our Fall Themed Horror Series. Today we are going for something a little different. We are looking at the 2002 surprise, ultra low budget, hit The Collingswood Story. Directed and written by Michael Costanza. The Collingswood Story is the progenitor of the computer screen horror genre. Movies like Host and Unfriended have a lot to thank The Collingswood Story for. It pretty much set the benchmark for this type of movie. Showing the world how to successfully use the Screenlife style of presentation for effective horror.

The Collingswood Story follows a short period in the life of young couple Rebecca and Johnny. The pair are attempting to navigate a long distance relationship. After interacting with an online psychic. It’s not long before some seriously strange revelations come to light that threaten more than just their relationship. Can a found footage movie filmed inside of two houses really qualify as a fall themed horror? Well, I am desperate so you better believe it can.

On a more serious note, there are plenty of fall themes here. We have Halloween, pumpkin carving and outdoor scenes with tons of fallen leaves. It’s not the most obvious autumn themed horror but, for me, it definitely counts. More to the point, it completely fits the bill when wanting to include something a bit different. What, you thought I was going to put something like The Lady in White on this list? Bah, too easy!

Computer Screen Supernatural Horror

The Collingswood Story is classed as a Computer Screen Horror. All conversations take place over a video chat app and all other footage is filmed selfie style with a handicam. It would be a decade before we saw another high profile computer screen horror movie. Megan is Missing attained similar levels of success in 2011 but that movie is a true horror travesty that barely deserves any kind of mention. The Collingswood Story plays out as something of a paranormal mystery film with a twist. Everything kicks off with a conversation the pair share with a psychic.

The tension builds palpably throughout the movie as we uncover the mystery of Collingswood. Rebecca is presented as a somewhat vulnerable girl. She is alone in a large house but dismisses many of Johnny’s concerns. Over time, a few twists begin to prove there may be truth to what the psychic is saying. The feeling of isolation grows throughout. Johnny’s inability to be with his girlfriend only adds to the sense of vulnerability. It’s a fun, somewhat old fashioned, tense mystery horror with a twist.

Unique and Innovative for the Time

The Collingswood Story should be lauded for doing something completely different. Back in 2002 there was nothing like this. It’s hard to describe this movie as a risk for the director, however. It was astonishingly low budget and nothing was expected to come of it. To say that it wasn’t daring, for the time, would be completely wrong. There was nothing like this in the horror scene back then. Sure, The Blair Witch Project had laid the tracks for found footage horror to be a viable money maker. The Collingswood Story, however, felt completely different from even that.

This was horror on a more minute scale and with an even tighter budget. There are virtually no cast members. There are no trips to interesting locations. Special effects are limited and there are no extravagant set ups. It is fantastically raw and about as DIY as you can get. Nothing else from the time feels anything like this. That is, in large part, down to its unique presentation. Sure, movies have used this formula again over the years but, back then, it was pretty much unheard of.

Webcam Horror

It would be false to suggest that video chats were non-existent back in the early 2000s. In fact, the first video conferencing call took place all the way back in 1931 between two AT&T offices in New York. Old 80’s commercials will occasionally show off video calling methods used for businesses. Sure, these weren’t particularly common and the technology was extremely rudimentary. It was clear, however, that the concept was there. Video phones for the deaf pushed this technology even further. Fast forward to 1991 and the invention of the first webcam by some Cambridge students. Suddenly, the possibilities of a cheap web based video communication system became feasible.

Yahoo was one of the first companies to bring webcam chats to the masses. This was back in the late 90s and early 2000s. Access was fairly limited. Internet connections were painfully slow and webcams were quite expensive. The infrastructure was there, however, and the potential uses were obvious. The Collingswood Story was right at the forefront of this technology. Costanza was ready and waiting to turn video calls into a horror movie. Needless to say, I am impressed and you should be too. Nowadays, everyone is walking around video chatting. The reality of the 2020s is that you can end up in someone’s call when you are buying toilet paper. How annoying! Back in the early 2000s, this didn’t happen. A fact that makes this film all the more impressive for its inventiveness.

Dekko Video Phone

Rebecca and Johnny use a piece of software called Dekko Video Phone. The software requires them to dial with their landline first. When the call connects they click a button to activate the video using their webcam. Bizarre, yes but also very inventive. It is clear that this technology is widespread. A whole bunch of comical chat lines exist and people are monetizing the service. The movie was actually filmed using a Sony HI8 Camcorder which is something of a blessing. How awful would this have looked using an old webcam? Try sitting through a movie filmed using 320 x 320 resolution at 1 frame a second. Utter sadness! Even worse, transmitted over 56k modem lines (hmm.. “sadness transmitted over 56k modem lines” sounds like the title of a Midwest emo track).

While showing its age, The Collingswood Story is not as bad looking as you might expect. This is definitely not 2002 webcam quality. I imagine some viewers will likely get a kick out of the Windows 98 style applications. The antique looking websites are rather amusing as well. Things have come on a lot in the past 20 years. This movie acts as a bit of a time capsule for the internet many of us grew up with.

The video call horror has been refined and, pretty much, perfected recently. Movies like Unfriended and Host have it down to an art. The Collingswood Story, in comparison, can feel old and a bit cheesy. The need for the characters to hang up to make other calls can disrupt the flow a little. The obvious edits stand out, as well, for how jarring they are. The actors here were not actually talking to each other. This becomes very obvious when characters change positions in between sentences. At times they basically teleport across rooms in a matter of milliseconds. It is easy to forgive, however. This was raw innovation working on a shoestring budget with limited technology. Comparing it to more recent, better polished movies is unfair. In fact, for something so low budget, it would be doing it a disservice.

Tense and Very Compelling

The thing that stands out about The Collingswood Story is how engaging the plot is. Other than the unique presentation, that is. Despite the limited filming locations and cast, it’s hard not to be impressed. It is genuinely captivating for much of its run time. The twists and turns come in frequently and the story develops at a fantastic pace. It keeps you interested throughout. The believable performances also help you buy into the events occurring.

It’s not a particularly scary film, if I am being honest. It aims to get into the viewer’s head by building an atmosphere of tension and apprehension. The film utilises the suggestion of something ominous in the town. Combine this with Rebecca’s sense of vulnerability and you have something unsettling. Johnny’s growing frustration with the distance between the pair is clear. His fear for Rebecca’s safety helps you to buy into the potential threat. The surprising ending comes out of nowhere and is genuinely very unexpected. It’s all done very well. The fact that Costanza did it on such a small budget is a testament to his ability to tell a decent story.

Decent Acting

Acting in The Collingswood Story is actually pretty decent. Johnny, played by Johnny Burton, is your sort of everyman normal dude. Concerned with his girlfriend’s safety, he appears thoughtful but somewhat insecure. Burton does a fine job portraying the character. He manages to get across the frustration of the separate living situations well. His friend Billy, played by Grant Edmons, is something of a comedy character. Edmons plays Billy for laughs and the friends have a somewhat comedic chemistry.

Stephanie Dees, as Rebecca, is fine. She does well portraying the sceptical girlfriend focussed on her school work. Prioritising personal progression over her relationship. Obviously moving away from friends and family for school means you are likely to put that first. Dees does a nice job of expressing Rebecca’s frustrations. She is struggling, after all, to split her time between work and relationships. I particularly liked her performance in the last 15 minutes. Her character experiences some interesting growth and develops a little.

The most experienced actor here is Diane Behrens who plays psychic Vera Madeline. She is suitably creepy. She manages to switch her personality quite well between scenes. It’s a convincingly kooky performance. I imagine some people might find it a little too cheesy and out of place, despite this. Behrens went on to have a great career and acts in big productions to this day.

Should You Watch The Colllingswood Story?

I definitely think you should watch The Collingswood Story. It’s something of an important movie in modern horror history, despite how much it flies under the radar. It pioneered a style that would go on to be used many times after. Sure, there are issues. It isn’t all that scary and the manner of recording and editing leaves the conversations feeling a bit stilted and inorganic. But what Michael Costanza achieved with so little is worthy of praise and attention. This is a very good movie that is still enjoyable to this day. All while acting as a fascinating time capsule of early 2000’s DIY horror fun.

Our Scoring Philosophy: A Fair Fight

Horror is a genre that thrives thanks to indie film makers and low budget creators. At Knockout Horror, we firmly believe that every movie that we review deserves a fair fight. That's why we grade on a curve. Our star ratings are all about context, judging a film on what it achieves with the resources it has.

A 4-star rating for a scrappy indie horror made for $10,000 is a testament to its ingenuity and raw power. A 4-star rating for a $100 million blockbuster means it delivered on its epic promises. We don't compare them side-by-side; we celebrate success in every weight class, from the back-alley brawler to the heavyweight champion. Please keep this in mind when considering star ratings.

Disclaimer: Images, posters, and video stills used in this review are the property of their respective copyright holders. They are included here for the purposes of commentary, criticism, and review under fair use. Knockout Horror makes no claim of ownership and encourages readers to support the official release of all films discussed.