Silent Night, Deadly Night (1984) review: the controversy behind the classic

Welcome to Knockout Horror. Today we reviewing Christmas slasher – Silent Night, Deadly Night.

A Fun Christmas Slasher

The story is pretty simple, as it was with most 80’s slashers. A young boy witnesses his parents being murdered by a maniacal killer dressed as Santa. Traumatised, the boy is sent to a psychiatric hospital and spends his youth despising anything to do with Christmas.

Years later, Billy is released from the hospital and is ready to start his life. Only, the spectre of Christmas still haunts him, prompting him to go on a murderous rampage of his own. Silent Night, Deadly Night is a good old fashioned Christmas Slasher in a similar vein to Black Christmas, and the like.

For the first half of the movie, Silent Night, Deadly Night doesn’t feel like a slasher at all. A heavy focus is placed on Billy’s childhood and his new job working at the grocery store. There is a surprising amount of story, perhaps even enough to put off pure slasher fans who just want to get to the action. Once it gets going, however, the kills come thick and fast and Billy’s childhood is well in the past.

It’s an absolute hoot for the most part and very typical of what you might expect. The usual slasher tropes are all here. There is lots of blood, limbs are removed, and inventive slayings abound. On top of that, there are more boobs than you can shake a candy cane at. You know how horror got down in the 80s.

Tons of controversy

Released around the Christmas holiday. Silent Night, Deadly Night caused an absolute uproar back in 1984. Times were a little different back then and people were even more sensitive than they are today. Well, with regards to religion they were, anyway.

“Silent Night, Deadly Night’s Christmas theme was already going to be a bit of a problem. The marketing relied heavily on the novelty factor so focused on the fact that the killer wears a Santa outfit.”

Silent Night, Deadly Night’s Christmas theme was already going to be a bit of a problem. The marketing relied heavily on the novelty factor so focused on the fact that the killer wears a Santa outfit. This became an enormous issue.

The release of Christmas Evil a few years before didn’t cause so much as a ripple. Silent Night, Deadly Night, however, was almost deliberately poking the bear. They actually had the temerity to advertise it during Little House on the Prairie! Surely they must have realised this was asking for trouble? The Parent and Teacher Association were up in arms about it.

Parents complained saying that their children were now terrified of Santa. Tristar pulled ads almost immediately and shortened the movie’s cinema run drastically. Naturally Siskel and Ebert pissed blood about how awful the movie was which didn’t help.

Needless to say, this isn’t a particularly controversial movie when viewed through a modern lens. Held up against things that come out nowadays, it is extremely middle of the road. It is fun to look back on these types of films and see how things have changed. Part of the reason people remember this movie is down to the controversy it caused.

Some really fun kills

We are here for violence, right and the kills are a tremendous amount of fun. I laughed out loud at a few as they are visually quite silly. Played by the imposing Robert Brian Wilson, Billy is not your typical slasher villain. He is a rather handsome guy with blonde hair and something of a baby face.

“The kills are a tremendous amount of fun. Billy’s size and strength leads to a number of rather unique kills, some of which are visually quite silly.”

Wilson would not look at all fitting of a terrifying villain were he not so physically large. Billy’s almost child-like features make him surprisingly easy to sympathise with, too. It’s hard not to feel a little bit sorry for Billy, given his back story. Some of the people he kills are absolute asshats as well so you may actually find yourself rooting for him to knock a few more names off that naughty list.

Billy’s size and strength leads to a number of rather unique kills. One of which had to be heavily edited for the censored American release because it was just too damn violent. He never really feels super human, though. In fact, at least one person puts up a hell of a fight and Billy takes a fair bit of damage. Again, this is another way in which Silent Night, Deadly Night feels quite different.

Acting is suitably hammy. Lilyan Chauvin is bags of fun as the cruel Mother Superior. Relishing the chance to play a harsh, domineering woman. Britt Leach, as Billy’s boss Mr Sims, has a great turn as a festive drunk on Christmas eve. Again, it’s hammy but a hell of a lot of fun.

“Acting is suitably hammy. Lilyan Chauvin is bags of fun as the cruel Mother Superior, relishing the chance to play a harsh, domineering woman.”

Horror vet Linnea Quigley has a fun but brief role. She ends up naked on a pool table but, this is Linnea Quigley, so you probably could have guessed that. The rest of the cast are pretty much what you would expect.

A brand new remake

Updating this review in December of 2025, we now have another remake of Silent Night, Deadly Night so that makes two reboots in 15 years. We actually checked out Silent Night, the original remake of this, a few days before reviewing the original. It was a perfectly adequate festive thriller and quite enjoyable.

The 2025 Silent Night, Deadly Night remake sticks closer to the original by sharing a protagonist though, once again, the plots differ in major ways. Feel free to check out that review but today we are here for the movie that started them all.

Our Scoring Philosophy: A Fair Fight

Horror is a genre that thrives thanks to indie film makers and low budget creators. At Knockout Horror, we firmly believe that every movie that we review deserves a fair fight. That's why we grade on a curve. Our star ratings are all about context, judging a film on what it achieves with the resources it has.

A 4-star rating for a scrappy indie horror made for $10,000 is a testament to its ingenuity and raw power. A 4-star rating for a $100 million blockbuster means it delivered on its epic promises. We don't compare them side-by-side; we celebrate success in every weight class, from the back-alley brawler to the heavyweight champion. Please keep this in mind when considering star ratings.